Sunday, April 1, 2007

Dear Harry

My dear Harry,
I hope you don't mind if I drop you a note from time to time over the next few months. You see, while I'm awaiting the final installment of your saga, I'm re-reading the first six books. And the more I read, the more I find myself wishing I could impart a few well-chosen words of advice. I'm not as old nor as wise as Dumbledore (in fact, I'm probably closest in age to Molly Weasley...and yes, I'm a Mom) but I can't shake the feeling that you need all the help you can get.

I just finished reading the chapter in Sorcerer's Stone where you and Ron knock out the 12-foot mountain troll that you accidentally locked in the girl's bathroom where Hermione was crying. I have always loved the action in this chapter for the way it began to cement the bonds of friendship between you, Ron and Hermione. And that's my first word of advice to you this evening: remember them. Be grateful for them. And let them help you.

I know from the end of Half-Blood Prince that you already feel grateful beyond words for their offer to go with you on your horcrux hunt. But there's a tiny bit of me that's worried you'll think twice about their offer and try to talk them out of it. Don't. It won't do a bit of good, because they'll just come anyway. Have you noticed how stubborn they both are? And how much they love you? A guy never had better friends, Harry, and you need your friends now.

Notice too, how their skills complement your's. You would never have gotten through many of the things you've had to do over the years without Ron and Hermione. Ron may act a bit daft at times, but when it comes to courage, the well runs deep in that boy (and in his whole family). He's also pretty good at thinking on his feet. Hermione's encyclopedic knowledge and incredible memory are also traits you're going to need. Frankly, you don't have much time to be looking things up in the Hogwarts library anymore...but with Hermione around, you won't need to. She's spent the last six years absorbing it all.

My second bit of advice: Don't judge a book by its cover. I could mean that literally, you know... you've had plenty of practice in mis-judging books. Tom Riddle's diary and the Half-Blood Prince's potions book both leap to mind. But in this case, I'm talking about people. I think you have become a fairly good judge of character over the years, but you've always tended to make snap judgments and to stick by some of your understandings or impressions of who people are -- sometimes longer than merited. You've got to let yourself look deeper than surface impressions. Remember how Neville just looked like a forgetful, scaredy-cat at the beginning? He's turned out to have the courage of a lion -- there's a reason he got put into Griffyndor! (You're going to need Neville!!!) Remember how looney and dreamy Luna seemed? Recall that she outlasted almost everyone in the battle at the DoM, and that her compassion shows acute understanding of the needs and feelings of others.

I'm heartened by your growing sense of pity (if not downright empathy) for your schoolboy nemesis, Draco Malfoy. Even Malfoy can change, Harry. Remember how he wavered and lowered his wand on the tower with Dumbledore? Don't underestimate the possibility that even some of the people you've thought of as enemies may turn out, in the end, to want to help you fight your much larger enemy. That's all I'll say about that -- for the moment.

If love is the power you have that Tom doesn't -- and I'd take Dumbledore's word to the bank on that one -- then look around and see who loves you. Lean on those folks, and don't underestimate their desire to help you in your darkest hour. You need them, not only the strength of their love, but their accumulated grit and wisdom and humor and stubbornness.

2 comments:

Erin said...

Ahhhhh, lovely letter... *sigh* Methinks Hedwig should be making a special delivery tonight! I especially think your advice about not judging a book by its cover is something Harry really ought to pay attention to.

On the one hand, his reliance on first impressions helps him to form such firm, valuable attachments to the likes of Hagrid, Ron, Hermione and Dumbledore. But sometimes he trusts too easily, and more often he is too easily poisoned by prejudice once someone has displayed distasteful qualities.

He can hardly be blamed, for instance, for loathing Snape at the moment, in the immediate aftermath of such a terrible moment that seemed to reveal the depth of Snape's malice, but up to that point he rejects almost any suggestion that Snape mightn't be so bad after all, even though he knows that McGonagall, Hagrid and, most of all, Dumbledore trust him, and even though he's seen with his own eyes the cruel manner in which he was treated by James. Perhaps the latter fuels his anger, though, since Snape introduced him to a side of his father he didn't want to know about...

Anyway, prime advice. Listen to her, Harry!!

Beth said...

So interesting that you used the term "first impressions"! So very Austen of you, dear Erin Elizabeth! ;-) But you know, Harry has more in common with Austen heroines than may seem obvious at first glance, and his "mistaken first impressions" are a big part of that. Or rather, the way he cements his first impressions so that it's very hard for him to change his mind and heart about someone.

It's interesting to consider what finally begins to sway Elizabeth Bennett...hearing the truth, seeing the truth lived out before her through courageous action which leads to her own admiration and finally love. Could we see Harry go through a similar (albeit no romantic) kind of metamorphosis in book 7?

You're right...I think we need to cut Harry some slack when it comes to Snape. He's just witnessed something that he can hardly believe -- something that I don't even think he thought Snape, much as he couldn't stand him, was even capable of -- and although I think there was much more to the situation than met the eye, I know I'd be feeling similar feelings in Harry's shoes. We just have to hope he doesn't get stuck in anger, resentment and what he believes to be the truth about Snape -- especially if those things divert him from what he needs to do to deal with his real nemesis. I think his friends and loved ones will help him in that...

Let me know if you see Hedwig!